Tasty must-try pies of the Central Coast

elegant image of pie and cutlery

Image credit: @SonomaBakery

elegant image of pie and cutlery

Image credit: @SonomaBakery

Congratulations, hungry soul! You've now got the Central Coast's ultimate pie guide in your hands...
When the rain pours or the tummy rumbles, there's no better calling to venture out and find a handmade, gourmet pie! Tuck into our local list for exactly where to find some top Coastie pie spots.

The Central Coast artisan bakery scene is blooming, and this means we are lucky to have several delicious locations across the region to enjoy a good Aussie pie. But also, premium pies, slow-cooked bbq brisket pies, savoury pies, sweet cherry pies, creamy mornay pies, veggie deluxe pies, vegan pies, gluten free pies, bake at home pies... the list goes on! 

If you fancy a tasty pastry package for lunch, dinner or your next Central Coast road trip, here are some excellent local spots selling pies you simply must try if you call yourself a true pie connoisseur.

And if you're more a sausage roll kind of vibe, or it's Central Coast pastry treats in general you're after, check out our baker's dozen regional guide here.

classy meat pie scene on plate
Bells Bakery & Larder, Killcare
Credit: @richard_mortimer_photo1
pies on warmer rack
Credit: @flourandco_
Your gourmet pie pit-stop list

Bells Bakery & Larder - The Scenic Road, Killcare

Broomfield Pie Co are now showcasing their pastry products at Bells Bakery & Larder in Killcare, which is an absolute treat for pie fans. If you haven't heard of Broomfield before, their pies are made with the best of local, seasonal produce, handcrafted with all butter pastry. Flavours change weekly and can include Wagyu beef and onion, chicken and leek, and vegetable with chip shop curry sauce all available for takeaway at an easy $10 per pie.

More on Bells Bakery & Larder
 

Bremen Patisserie - West Street, Umina

Bremen Patisserie has been serving gourmet award-winning pies to the community and its guests for more than 30 years, home to the 'best pies in the universe' according to its high street sign - including the famous 'Flaming Ron' fuelled with the Carolina Reaper chilli, which is more than 300 times hotter than a jalapeño! Locals claim it's certainly hot, but absolutely delicious. Their pastry products are baked daily on the premises by a team of qualified bakers and pastry cooks using fresh fruits, vegetables, meats and spices to create flavourful fillings include chicken korma, beef burgundy and mushroom, mango chicken and peanut curry, and veggie mornay.

More on Bremen Patisserie

Brown Sugar Bakery - Forresters Beach Road, Forresters Beach

Just off the main road in 2260 you can easily pull into a row of shops featuring the much-loved family-run Brown Sugar Bakery. Headed up by baker Paul this Forries bakery is open every day of the week from 6am! The team are committed to the highest quality pies and sausage rolls, including standout favourites Mushy Pea (yep, the peas are inside the pastry), chicken curry, and classic Aussie meat pies. While you're there, don't miss stocking up on the handmade artisan loaves too!

More on Brown Sugar Bakery

Burnt Honey Bakery - Long Jetty and Copacabana

This Central Coast bakery powerhouse needs no introduction - because if you haven't found yourself queueing on a weekend at Copacabana for a Copa Queen and coffee, have you even been to the Central Coast?! Jokes aside, there are some seriously delicious pie flavours available at Burnt Honey and handmade by their talented baker team, owners and partners, Hayley and Jo. For example, imagine parking up in a cosy spot by the sea on a grey day and devouring a lentil shepherds pie with confit garlic and rosemary mash, or a Moroccan chickpea pie with housemade jam! Pie heaven is real. Keep an eye on their socials for the latest weekly treats to preorder, and arrive early as they always sell out!

More on Burnt Honey Bakery

Flour and Co - Toowoon Bay Road, Toowoon Bay

With over 30 years in the bakery business, all their tasty pies are waiting in the warmer for your post beach refuelling and each handmade from scratch every sunrise, with flavours including your classic meat pie, veggie options and curry sensations. 

More on Flour & Co

Heatherbraes Pies - Old Pacific Highway, Ourimbah

An essential stop for pie lovers is of course the top pie destination in the state! Since opening in the 1990s in Raymond Terrace, Heatherbraes now has a home on the Central Coast since July 2022 - and our tummies are rumbling for a visit! Such an easy pit-stop just off the M1 near Ourimbah, this is the place to go if 'pie for dinner' is your vibe. Styled like a pub and sporting daily special flavours, each pie is made fresh on site prepared to its own unique recipe before the first surfer even hits a wave every morning.

More on Heatherbraes Pies

Inner Glow Kiosk - Ocean View Road, Ettalong & Mann Street, Gosford

The cutest store just opposite the Ettalong Galleria precinct, where you will find coffee, fresh juice, fresh food, fresh flowers and as of recently - they've announced fresh pies too! The team are adding vegan pies to their existing plant-based takeaway offerings, with four fancy flavours available served with or without a side salad, such as chunky mushroom and potato mash with perfect flaky pastry. You can also pop into their Gosford location for the goods - right opposite the Leagues Club Park.

More on Inner Glow Kiosk

Jerry's One Stop Cafe - George Downes Drive, Kulnura

Known as a perfect hinterland stop for food, coffee and  a popular motorcycle meeting point, Jerry's is also great for hitting that hot pie craving! Family run since 2005, we'd recommend trying the Ned Kelly Pie, which we're warned may look like your ordinary potato pie - but what’s inside makes it a crowd favourite...

More on Jerry's Cafe

cutlery cutting pie
Credit: @JerrysCafeKulnura
three pies on plate with herby topping
Credit: @RiseBakeryEttalong
pie in hand in car
Burnt Honey Bakery
Credit: @Happydayzcentralcoast
veggie pie on plate with salad
Credit: @InnerGlowKiosk
Your gourmet pie pit-stop list continued...

Ken's Humble Pie Shop - Coral Street, The Entrance

After a gorgeous walk along The Entrance foreshore, head to where there is often a line-up into Ken’s for their range of incredible daily fresh pie varieties, pelican-shaped novelty meringues and other traditional baked goods.

More on Ken's Humble Pie Shop

Pie in the Sky Bakery - The Entrance Road, Erina

Been shopping at Erina Fair and crave a proper juicy pie on your way home to refuel? Drop into Palm Court just off the main road to browse over 30 scrumptious varieties of beef, chicken and vegetarian pies at this dedicated pie bakehouse. 

More on Pie in the Sky

Rise Bakery - Ocean View Road, Ettalong

As well as championing sourdough on the Peninsula of the Coast, RISE do artisan pies! Small batch pies are waiting in the warmer for you, just perfect when the weather turns but you can still enjoy a fresh bakery treat with a wander around the Ettalong Galleria precinct. If it's the weekend, get in early for flavours including slow cooked brisket, chicken mornay and veggie coconut curry, generously topped with smokey tomato relish.

More on RISE Artisan Bakery

Saddles -  Ashbrookes Road, Mount White

If you’re touring the Pacific Highway scenic route - Tourist Drive 33 - pick up a fresh flaky pie for your onwards road trip. Located just off the scenic Pacific Highway at Mt White, you will find an array of savoury and sweet luxury takeaway treats available in this hinterland hideaway cafe.

More on Saddles Mt White

Shhmoakesy's Gourmet Pies - Kincumber

A bit of a delicious enigma on the Central Coast, you won't be disappointed once your taste buds discover Shhmoakesy's. Popping up at local markets including Terrigal on the first Saturday of the month, Gosford Markets on the third Saturday of the month, Long Jetty on the last Saturdays of the month, and Avoca Beach Markets on the last Sunday of the month - make your plan of attach! You can also visit local village stores stocking their gourmet pies including Pomegranate by Fresko Cafe in Kincumber, Bottle Tree Cafe in Bensville, and Kindred Spirits Dog Cafe Yattalunga. Watch this space - there's some more local spots to come soon. Enjoy their menu of gourmet pies, premium pies, gluten free pies and... grab a souvenir pie t shirt!

More on Shhmoakesy's

Sonoma Bakery - Church Street, Terrigal

Introducing their new 'Bake at Home' gourmet pie range in Terrigal, Sonoma offer six deliciously decadent sweet and savoury treats that include Chunky Beef Pie, Country Chicken Pie, Pork Sausage Rolls, Mini Quiches, Apple Pie and Double Choc Chip Cookies. Each are oven bake ready and simple to prepare. We recommend their family-sized Chunky Beef Pie, made with the flakiest Pate Brisee, fall apart tender pieces of beef slow cooked in a white wine gravy with aromatic herbs thyme and rosemary, enveloped in a whey butter ruff puff pastry... did we mention you can order online direct to your door?

More on Sonoma Terrigal
 

The Fat Goose - Killcare Road, Killcare / Hardys Bay

Order a hearty pie from their display cabinet and sit in with a side salad for the proper Killcare lunch experience. Or grab one to go and devour at one of the foreshore's picnic spots looking out at Hardys Bay and Ettalong. On the bakery side, you’ll also find hand-crafted Italian style breads, rye loaves, classic European pastries, gluten free breads and sweets, muffins, friands, and quiches, all baked daily in house at The Fat Goose.

More on The Fat Goose

open meat pie with gourmet brisket filling
Credit: @ShhmoakesysGourmetPies
tray of pies on warmer rack
Credit: @KensHumblePieShop

Share the love

Do you have a fresh suggestion we’ve missed, or want to see your local business featured? We'd love to hear it – simply get in touch here with a few lines about your idea, or jump on our radar by creating a free Central Coast business or event listing here.

 

Don't forget – when sharing your love for local on the Central Coast, tag #LoveCentralCoast and mention us on Instagram and Facebook.